Salut! Live

Image: Simone J Rudolphi 

 

MUSIC TO HELP US THROUGH LOCKDOWN

I am not sure whether Nick Hornby had the same problem when he wrote High Fidelity. For me, no sooner is a list created - favourite this, favourite that - than glaring omissions begin to glare. When posting my top 10s for male and female singers, live bands, acoustic bands and duos in my Lockdown sounds series, I did take care to explain how changeable my selections were.

You'd find competing lists if you had the time and inclination to trawl through the Salut! Live archive ...

A photograph I have hanging on the wall in France. It shows my reflection in the mirror as I interview Altan's Mairéad Ní Mhaonaigh one night in Donegal

MUSIC TO HELP US THROUGH LOCKDOWN

I am grateful to everyone who has taken the trouble to respond to my series of Lockdown sounds, artists male and female, duos, bands seen live and so on .. with singer-songwriters to come.

Those responses have come directly to Salut! Live and at Twitter or Facebook. From Jon Marks came a quite exceptional effort.

He's lovely bloke I've met all of once (drinks before a Portsmouth-Sunderland match; I support Sunderland, he supports Spurs but lives in Pompey after which the detail of connections loses relevance to a folk music site).

But he has gone to the bother of replicating my device of listing top 10s in each category (when not inventing his own). His follow:

Paul Brady performs Arthur McBride. Image reproduced from Flickr with kind consent of David Sutherland

MUSIC TO HELP US THROUGH LOCKDOWN

Not even the readers of Salut! Live are wholly on my side. My folk tastes are unusual and I cannot be surprised that few share them. Kate Rusby once told me she was quite pleased this type of music wasn't for everyone (though, logically, it should be).

But I persevere. So far, we've had favourite male and females singers and favourite bands. I am delighted that so many people have bothered to offer their responses and make own suggestions.

Now it's time for duos and acoustic bands and I will not, for the purposes of this exercise, restrict my choices to those seen live. I'll add an asterisk to each selection where I have seen them up close and personal, or from row Z in the gods. And I have used a little licence, leaving out some of those mentioned in other categories even though they might fit again.

First duos. And this, 100 per cent, is folk and blues so avert your eyes if not for you...

When I bumped into Richard Thompson relaxing at Cropredy before the Liege and Lief line-up, minus Sandy, took stage

MUSIC TO HELP US THROUGH LOCKDOWN

Move on to bands, the man said, so we shall. If a top 10 of male or female singers, from a lifetime of listening to music, is hard enough, limiting a line-up of bands to 10 is frankly impossible.

I love folk music and folk-rock but what about all the blues, rock, pop and even country groups I've thoroughly enjoyed, not to mention classical ensembles?

For the purposes of this little list, then, I shall exclude classical music altogether and restrict my choice to bands I have seen live. And even then its tough.

This is my selection. I have listed them in order of how much pleasure each has given me, not because I necessarily believe them to be the best band in bather world, second best and so on

MUSIC TO HELP US THROUGH LOCKDOWN

I promised a top 10 of male singers - just my own preferences - and invite you to list yours.

You may also pop back to https://www.salutlive.com/2020/04/your-favourite-10-singers-1-female-sandy-denny-and-billie-holliday-head-my-list.html and offer your top 10 female vocalists.

Image: Jef Aresol

MUSIC TO HELP US THROUGH LOCKDOWN

This was an evolving Salut! Live post.

It attracted gratifying reader response although most of the 33 comments originated at social media mentions of the piece, not here.

Since we're all trying to find ways of occupying ourselves in lockdown, let's revisit the theme. Just list your all-time favourite female singers, which I'l broaden to include any genre.

I will move on to men later ... The article appeared in November 2017. If you want to see how readers reacted then, check it out here.

I will reflect for a day or so and say by way of a comment below whether my own list has changed again ...

Buy Janis Joplin's Greatest Hits album at Salut! Live's Amazon record shelf by clicking on this caption