Garth Hudson – a musical giant: RIP
A song for Burns’s Night

Those Dylan covers: your nominations

Colin Randall writes: of the three Salut! Live contributors who have been posting items relating to Bob Dylan to coincide with the arrival of A Complete Unknown in UK cinemas, I was last to see the movie and the least passionate Dylan fan among us. I dd not stop liking him when he went electric; on the contrary Blonde on Blonde was and remains a favourite of mine. But it was also the last Dylan album I bought. I just began to like him less.

A Complete Unknown reminds me of how much I loved his early music and all he seemed to represent to my generation.

Opinions vary but, to me, the film is a triumph. Here I shall limit my thoughts to the music.  I cannot improve on Bill Taylor's film review. Timothée Chalmnent (Dylan), Monica Barbaro (Joan Baez), Edward Norton (Pete Seeger) and Boyd Holbrook (Johnny Cash) perform the songs of their characters with commendable respect and competence.

Dylan 1963 - 1

Unknown author: from the  1964 yearbook of St Lawrence University

That brings me to the reason for this closing piece in the series. Countless artists have covered Dylan. Bill, Andrew Curry and I set out our choices in this article. I then drew as much attention as I could around social media, inviting others to nominate there own favourite alternative versions of his work from the period dealt with by the film, 1961-65.

Despite Salut!  Live's encouragingly high readership levels, few of our visitors leave comments whereas people are invariably quick to respond to posts at, for example, relevant Facebook groups. Here, with links to the groups so that you can explore further, is a short selection of those responses, all reproduced from Facebook:

The Bob Dylan Fan Club 

Hank Garfield (who also correctly pointed out that one of my choices, Jimi Hendrix’s  All Along the Watchtower was from outside the designated period):

Outlaw Blues by Grace Slick and the Great Society.

The UK and Irish Folk & Acoustic G0s-80s Group  

Mike Kenny (one of several to choose this):

To Ramona by Sinead Lohan

Salut! Live Facebook Group:

Steve Yates:

Masters of War by Martin Simpson 

There were votes, too, for Maggie Holland, Bryan Ferry, Manfred Mann, Fairport Convention, Julie Driscoll, The Band, the Byrds, Chris Smither, Old Blind Dogs, Ralph McTell, Pete Townshend, Nic Jones and many, many more.

Please follow the Links above to the groups I've mentioned  plus two others I haven't but which I heartily recommend: Uncharted Jukebox and the 60s 70s Folk Music Group.

Our thanks to all who came up with ideas.

My parting thought: as one who has quite often preferred a Dylan cover to Dylan Dylan, I should add that good as the actors were when singing his songs, I enjoyed even more the real thing that accompanied the rolling credits.

Join the Salut! Live Facebook group. Visit us at https://www.facebook.com/groups/2902595146676633/. You'll get there immediately if you're already on Facebook and it's simple and free to join.

Comments

Bill Taylor

Couldn't agree more about Dylan hitting his peak with "Blonde on Blonde." The last of his albums that I bought, too. I can and do still listen to his early stuff with the greatest pleasure - and without the pressure I used to put on myself to try to figure what his lyrics meant. His later music? Some of it, yes. Most of it, not so much.
There again, I was so much older then. I'm younger than that now.
(Let's see... who was it who first said that? The name's on the tip of my tongue...)

Bill Taylor

Nice to see “A Complete Unknown” get 8 Oscar nominations, including Chalamet, Barbaro and Norton. Very well-deserved.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)