From the Cranberries and Christy Moore to Sharon Shannon and the Dubliners. An imaginary St Patrick's Day CD
March 15, 2024
Sunday is St Patrick's Day and, much of the world over, parades, concerts and serious drinking will mark Ireland's special day,
Salut! Live's editorial team - Colin Randall and Andrew Curry - have known each other electronically for years, a virtual friendship based on their shared love of folk music and Sunderland AFC. Not until last Monday had they met.
Over fairly basic Lebanese nosh in South Kensington, they drew up separate lists of candidates for what would be a commemorative St Paddy's CD if only this site had the means to organise such luxuries.
Image By Andreas F Borchert
So here we go, seven tracks and one side each so maybe it's vinyl, not a CD. Apologies to countless terrific artists who also deserved to be included. Maybe we should have gone for a box set.
Links in the song titles will take you through to Spotify, if you want to listen.
Colin Randall's choice
1 Paul Brady: Arthur McBride. My Desert Island Discs selection as the one stand-out piece. Brady packs social history, grim humour and superb musicianship into this finest of press gang songs
2 Altan - John Doherty Reels. No compilation of Irish music would be complete without a set of tunes, Altan deliveer traditional music just about as good as it gets.
3 Christy Moore - Smoke and Strong Whiskey. An accomplished songwriter and magical interpreter of other people's work, Moore is also a supreme showman with captivating stage presence. This is one of his, a perceptive portrait of Irisb social ills
4 Dance to Tipperary - Fields of Athenry. Born in Dublin, adopted by Celtic fans, stolen by Liverpool supporters, Pete St John's song was a favouite of Paddy Sheehan, Corkman and late father of some of Colin’s closest friends. He would barely recognise this pulsating techno version sung to and with a Celtic Park crowd.
5 The Cranberries - Zombie. The Troubles inspired many better songs than this but it is a good and powerful one reacting to the 1993 IRA bombing that killed two children in Warrington. Plus I owe Dolores O'Riordan a posthumous apology for once, long ago, being unkind, wrongly, about her songwriting abilities.
6 The Chieftains with Joan Osborne - Raglan Road. There have been many excellent treatments of Patrick Kavanagh's poem, set to a traditional tune. This combines the Chieftains' towering musicianship and the beauty of Osborne's singing.
7 Glen Hansard & Friends - The Auld Triangle. The Royal Albert Hall is the unlikely setting as Hansard oozes charm while leading fellow performers and audience in a hearty singsong of the prison ballad in the presence of Michael D Higgins during the first state visit by an Irish president to the UK, in 2014.
Andrew Curry's choice
Donal Lunny, False Fly: A seven year girl outwits the Devil, who has appeared to her as an insect. This is something of a family favourite, from Lunny’s outstanding record Coolfin. Maighréad and Triona Ní Dhomhnaill are the vocalists.
Luka Bloom, City of Chicago: Perhaps the best song about Irish emigration, written and perfomed by.Luka Bloom—Christy Moore’s brother.
Mary Black (with Seamus Begley), Bruach Na Carraige Báine: Mary Black duets with the traditional Irish musician Seamus Begley on a traditional Gaelic air that was first collected in 1806.
Sharon Shannon, Galway Girl: A heart mended and broken in an hour. Sharon Shannon and Mundy perform Galway Girl live in the middle of Galway.
Martin Hayes and Dennis Cahill, Paddy Fahey’s Reel. From their sparse, spare record Lonesome Touch, one of the great Irish fiddle records. Hayes’s touch is gorgeous.
Cara Dillon, She Moved Through The Fair. A classic voice sings one of the classic Irish songs.
The Dubliners, Seven Drunken Nights: In which an adulterous wife runs rings round her drunken husband, and who can blame her if he’s always drunk? The perfect Dubliners’ song. I’m hoping the other artists in this list will all join them onstage for this one.
There’s a Salut Live playlist of this imaginary CD here. But of course we’ve missed things here. Tell us what else you’d want to see on this compilation—in the comments or at the Facebook group.
Join the Salut! Live Facebook group. Visit this link now
You beat me to it with "Smoke and Strong Whiskey." Superb song. Ah well, I'll start my list with another of Christy Moore's, "Missing You," about an Irishman, one of many, exiled in London:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6EhcP81Hg4
Van Morrison, with the Chieftains, "Carrickfergus" - a dying man taking a bittersweet look back:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bSngcH-TVWU
The Pogues, "Sally MacLennane" apparently inspired by a bar Shane MacGowan's uncle ran in Dagenham which catered to Irish workers at the nearby Ford plant. Great, raucous, boozy fun:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mz8THBdHRyI
The Barleycorn's "The Men Behind the Wire," written by the band's Paddy McGuigan about British military raids in Northern Ireland and the hundreds held without trial at prison camps such as Long Kesh:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CmpTVe1DrsI
"Whiskey in the Jar," a traditional classic - but not a traditional version. Nor is it the heavy metal Metallica rendition (which I love). I'm going with Thin Lizzy. Irish song, Irish band:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6WDSY8Kaf6o
Lots of versions around of "Rocky Road to Dublin" which tells of a young man's adventures and the people he meets as he sets out to seek his fortune. My favourite is by The Kings of Connaught:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNHafuFbxLc
"Wild Mountain Thyme" has a mixed ancestry - originally written as "The Braes of Balquhither" by a late 18th century Scottish poet, Robert Tannahill, and adapted about a century later by Belfast's Francis McPeake, who died in 1971. Again, lots of versions since it was recorded by McPeake's family in the 1950s. I like the way the Byrds perform it:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IEwqhaikDmg
Posted by: Bill Taylor | March 15, 2024 at 06:06 PM
Great suggestions, Bill. Box set it may well have to be
Posted by: Colin Randall | March 15, 2024 at 07:12 PM