What was your route to folk music? Here's John Mayall's part in mine
Song of the Day Revisited: Tim Hart and Maddy Prior - Dancing at Whitsun

Cover Story: (61) Underneath the Stars. Kate Rusby, Voces8 or Western Illinois University Singers

Choirs can work wonders with songs created for other settings.

In St Bride's, just off Fleet Street in London and commonly known as the journalists' church, I have attended several moving memorial services for former colleagues. And I remember in particular the St Bride's choir presenting its beautiful arrangement of With or Without You as part of the commemoration of my friend David Graves, who was almost as much a fan of U2 as he was of Wolverhampton Wanderers.

The British composer, arranger, orchestrator, and singer Jim Clements has turned one of Kate Rusby's most popular songs, Underneath the Stars, into an exquisite choral piece.

His sublime arrangement has become widely known, adopted by choirs around the world, and it inspires the latest edition of our Cover Story series.

1619px-KK_00587

Voces8 by Lauravoces8.foundation - Kaupo Kikkas 

 

There is no strict need to compare any of the choral versions with Rusby's original as the differing approach essentially makes them two distinct songs.

But it is worth noting that the UK ensemble Voces8, which does indeed feature eight voices, has attracted 1.1 million views for a YouTube clip of a performance recorded at the Gresham Centre in London (a burst of mental arithmetic suggests Rusby's own versions add up to to about the same).

Because they are so different, I will simply invite you to enjoy both Rusby singing her song at the Cambridge Folk festival in 2005 and two choral treatments, Voces8 and one from the Western Illinois University Singers.

It is an easy job to locate others; I recall coming across choirs from South Africa, New Zealand, Ireland and the UK when I looked up the song and I know there are more.

 

     

 

The song has also given its name to a festival run each summer by the cottage industry that supports Rusby's musical exploits.

Tickets for the 2021 event, at Cinderhill Farm, Cawthorne, bang in Rusby family territory near Barnsley, are on sale and the festival will go ahead from July 30 to Aug 1 subject to where we are then with the pandemic.

 

 

In the meantime, you can have a look at Rusby's plans for a quite different kind of performance, a streamed edition of her Hand Me Down album featuring outstanding covers of pop songs that will be online from April 10 to May 22. I wrote about it here.

 

 My postings at Facebook about this song have prompted a good deal of discussion (at the English Folk Music group, which you must join to see, and my own pages, which you don't). Some of this is reproduced in Comments below.

Once you've explored choral versions of Underneath the Stars  - or before, indeed instead, if you prefer - see what Kate Rusby does with her own song.

 

Comments

Bill Taylor

Maybe I'm just not the choral-music type but for me the choirs here, flawless though their voices are, take all the feeling out of the song and turn it into something fault-free but also emotion-free - an insipid watercolour, if you will, rather than a deeply hued oil painting. Rusby, on the other hand, digs deep into the song and brings it to life. And I loved the muted brass behind her. This one's a work of art.

Enid Buhler

Totally agree with Bill here. The choir versions are undoubtedly very good - flawlessly nice so to speak - but they leave me cold. Kate Rusby's own version, on the other hand, gives me goosebumps.

Joan Dawson

I think the choral versions are lovely too, they drew me in and create a feeling of stillness rather than the emotion you'd get from Kate's singing. I agree that they can't be compared as they're completely different genres, it just happens to be the same sobg, but if I'd not made out the words 'underneath the stars' I might not have realised that's what it was. Itdefinitely loses something in being sung in received pronunciation! Folk choirs manage to keep the folky feel of songs for multiple voices so it can be done. I'd very happily listen to both but treat them as entirely different things. I have to say the King's Singers' version Dance to thy Daddy is a bit odd, as the dialect is integral to the whole song and the link to the lives of the people singing it. Has to be Bob Fox; Nancy Kerr does a fine version. But because the lyrics to Kate's song are universal I think adapting it works. Hadn't realised all that before I started writing this!

Colin Randall

I cannot my resist repeating my old David Swarbrick anecdote. I was in Robin’s Hood Bay at the home of Martin Carthy, interviewing him. He told me of the time he was trying out something new on guitar and fearing it wouldn’t work. “You can do anything you want with music’” Swarb reassured him. “It won’t mind.”

I’d just add that I do prefer Rusby singing her own song but the choral arrangement creates something else, also valid

Mark Williams

Via Facebook

I have immense respect for the talent of Voces8, though I'm not always a fan of their repertoire choice. This is exquisite though.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)