Cover Story: (60) The Apprentice's Song. Ian Campbell Folk Group or the Johnstons
The Byrds: when folk-rock got higher and higher

A Song That Changed My Life: (1) Buffy Sainte-Marie revisited on her 80th birthday

Feb 20 2021 update: the great Buffy Sainte-Marie is 80 today. Hard to believe (until you remember your own advancing age) but today's the day. I hope she is in robust health and realises how revered she continues to be by discerning music lovers.

I am marking Buffy's birthday by reproducing an item published in a very short Salut! Live series entitled A Song That Changed My Life about her outstanding piece of Indigenous anger, My Country 'Tis of Thy People You're Dying.

Happy birthday, Buffy, and many happy returns ... 

Photo: Dr Peter Stockdale via Wikipedia Commons

Salut! Live has a habit of launching new series. Some last, some struggle to get started, some die out after a few instalments.
If we had a bigger audience, I'd throw this one out to you all. Is there a song (or tune) that made such an impact on you that it could be said to have changed your life, even if only a little?
There may be more than one, influencing different changes.
Come to think of it, I'll throw it out to you anyway.
I shall kick it off with the first song that sprang to mind as I contemplated the series.
Please do make contact - write to this e-mail address - if you have one you'd like to have your say about.
As you'll see from the second instalment - already written, by my old friend Bill Taylor - it doesn't need to be folk, folk-rock or roots ... we all, or most of us, have broader tastes ...

Now that you're wondering how must they feel Meaning them that you've chased across America's movie screens ...

My generation of British kids knew what was what when it came to westerns. The cowboys were the good guys (except when they were bandits), the "indians" or "Red Indians" were bloodthirsty savages. There was no halfway house.

None of us could guess then, as we watched the cowboys chase or be chased by indians, that the men we saw as heroes would in all likelihood be the ancestors of NRA neanderthals who believe the way to stop school massacres is to arm everyone from teachers to janitor. Or the kind of white trash that chanted "send her back" when Trump  insulted four Democrats with origins deemed un-American.

Until I heard Buffy Sainte-Marie singing My Country Tis of Thy People You're Dying, I had given scarcely a thought to the injustices suffered by North America’s earliest inhabitants.

The anguish and anger that streamed from the lyrics changed all that.

I was always drawn to protest songs.

Like my pal, Bill Taylor, who thought his first contribution to this series might be A Hard Rain's Gonna Fall (in the event he chose a Beach Boys song, Don't Worry Baby instead), I turned to Bob Dylan for the best of the genre.

Then I explored other singers and writers and realised that protest stretched beyond horror at the US war in Vietnam, nuclear weapons and the way black people were treated. There were Irish protest songs, a rich seam of English and Scottish mining (and other workers') protest songs, Woody Guthrie, songs about the Spanish Civil War ... and Buffy Sainte-Marie's magnificent, searing description of the plight of what I thought it was now acceptable to call Native Americans.

Bill grew up, as I did, in County Durham but has lived in Canada for most of his adult life. He points out that in the ever-changing politically correct glossary of his adopted country, Buffy is "native Canadian or, as we say here, First Nations or Indigenous (hard sometimes to keep up with the latest acceptable terminology") ...

Her own words matter a lot more. My Country Tis Of Thy People You're Dying appeared on a 1966 album.

For all I know, she wrote the song some time before then. Whether it poured out in one session of writing, or evolved over time, it's a gem, even if Soldier Blue may have been a bigger it and Up Where We Belong, which she co-wrote, will certainly have made her a good deal more money.

Buffy Saint-Marie is now 78 (or was when this article first appeared). I salute her for her wonderful, eye-opening work and commend to you a fine new interview by Ruth Hopkins for Teen Vogue. Now let these lyrics sink in:

Now that we're harmless and safe behind laws
Now that my life's to be known as your 'Heritagé
Now that even the graves have been robbed
Now  that our own chosen way is a novelty
Hands on our hearts we saluts you your victory
Choke on your blue white and scarlet hypocrisy



Bill Taylor

Nicely done! You're a hard act to follow...

Trevor Corkin

Just found your blog & don’t know if this is the correct place to post but were you aware that Ex-Fairport singer Judy Dyble had passed away, and more recently Trees singer Celia Humphris! I believe they were both 71 years of age.

Colin randall

Good win today, Trevor (fellow Sunderland supporter)!

Yes, I knew about Judy - - But not Celia

Bill Taylor

My favourite of her works is "Soldier Blue," which was the theme song for the controversial 1970 film of the same name, dealing with the Sand Creek Massacre of Cheyenne and Arapahoe by the U.S. Cavalry in 1864. It's a beautiful piece of music. I'm not 100% certain she wrote it for the movie. Its climax is gruelling to watch but that's worth seeking out, too.

Jim Peale

Via Facebook

Isn't she something? So talented and still so beautiful!

Carol Freeman

Via Facebook

Seen her both perform and be interviewed in the past few years at the Smithsonian Museum of the American Indian in New York. She is still extraordinary.

Phil Parent

Via Facebook

Back in the late on mid 50s Sebago Lake Campground beach at night singing folk songs around the fire. Buffy was the hit of the crowd

Truth Seeker

Wow, to me that sounds like nails on a chalkboard! Hard to imagine how she became so famous and yet I couldn't name a single song sang she recorded if my life depended on it. Now that it has come out about her being a grifter and pretend indigenous person, which wouldn't be the worst thing a person has ever done, but the way she dis-honored her true American Italian heritage and screwed over her real family, I can't imagine how one would feel if this grifter was the one that inspired me to change my life. I would feel like I was betrayed. Try to remember your own actions and intentions were true, even if the inspiration came from a lie. That's the dichotomy of life. The Ying and the Yang are not two separate things. It is one thing with two sides. Just like Buffy Fake Marie.

colin randall

OK. Let’s accept for sake of argument that her relationship with the truth, at least in so far as her origins and ethnicity are concerned, are like Trump or Boris’s relationship with the truth on just about anything. But you havent identified a single error, distortion or even example of hyperbole in the song. You do, however, display ignorance of music. You’ve never heard of Soldier Blue, Universal Soldier or Until It’s Time For You To Go? To name just three classics.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)