Lockdown sounds: now for acoustic bands and duos. Planxty and the McGarrigles top my lists
April 21, 2020
Paul Brady performs Arthur McBride. Image reproduced from Flickr with kind consent of David Sutherland
MUSIC TO HELP US THROUGH LOCKDOWN
Not even the readers of Salut! Live are wholly on my side. My folk tastes are unusual and I cannot be surprised that few share them. Kate Rusby once told me she was quite pleased this type of music wasn't for everyone (though, logically, it should be).
But I persevere. So far, we've had favourite male and females singers and favourite bands. I am delighted that so many people have bothered to offer their responses and make own suggestions.
Now it's time for duos and acoustic bands and I will not, for the purposes of this exercise, restrict my choices to those seen live. I'll add an asterisk to each selection where I have seen them up close and personal, or from row Z in the gods. And I have used a little licence, leaving out some of those mentioned in other categories even though they might fit again.
First duos. And this, 100 per cent, is folk and blues so avert your eyes if not for you...
1 Kate and Anna McGarrigle - sublime sounds from Quebec, rarely better than on this clip. RIP Kate ...
2 * Andy Irvine and Paul Brady - their eponymous album was released in 1976 but remains a classic in the history of folk music
3 * Show of Hands - always a delight to hear on record or see live
4 WAS* Silly Sisters - two essential female voices of English folk, belonging to June Tabor and Maddy Prior
NOW - Sorry but Maddy and June, great artists that they are, must give up their place to Richard and Linda Thompson, inexplicably overlooked
5 * Martin Carthy and Dave Swarbrick - I once persuaded a good friend, Geoff Carnan, to go with me to see them in a Sunderland folk club even though it meant hitching 30 miles home afterwards and it was his 21st birthday. I vividly remember the joy and the guilt and am pleased Swarb lived long enough to revive the duo in later life.
6 * Graham and Eileen Pratt - classy arrangements and, from Eileen in particular, stunning vocals
7 * Bert Jansch and John Renbourn - both lost to us now but for ever remembered for their outstanding guitar playing
8 * Kate Rusby and Kathryn Roberts - their spell as a duo produced the folk album of the 1990s
9 * Bob Fox and Stu Luckley - Bob has had other excellent collaborators, notably Benny Graham and a former Lindisfarne member, Billy Mitchell. Nowt So Good'll Pass, with Luckley, was a gem of an album of North-eastern music
10 * Sonny Terry and Brownie McGhee - I had to find room for my favourite blues duo, whose music I regularly listen to decades after both died
Sadly, the arbitrary limit of 10 meant I had to exclude several other exceptional pairings, including John Spiers/Jon Boden, Maire Ni Chathasaigh/Chris Newman, Nancy Kerr/James Fagan, Tom McConnell/Nancy Cato, Simon Mayor/Hilary James, Jacqui/Bridie and more besides. Apologies to all and plenty of others overlooked.
1 Planxty - the ultimate Irish supergroup (first line-up: Christy Moore, Andy Irvine, Donal Lunny, Liam O'Flynn. Paul Brady was among later members
2 Bothy Band - Irish traditional music as good as it gets
3 * Dervish - tip-top instrumental technique and flair crowned by the mesmerising vocals of Cathy Jordan
4 Was * Bitter Withy - recalled from first encounters with the excellent, versatile Scottish singer Barbara Dickson ....
Stop Press: may need to make way for Therapy, so fondly remembered from folk club days in Darlington and Bishop Auckland and by Bill Taylor in Comments below
5 Bellowhead - gloriously but surely economically challenged English big band. Their clips are made for binge-watching. But still waiting for John Spiers's response to my offer of a gentle plug for his efforts online to stave off poverty
6 * Touchstone - Irish/American fusion dominated by Triona Ni Dhomnhaill (ex-Bothy Band) and Claudine Langille. The short-lived collaboration yielded just two albums, but Jack Haggerty is one of the pieces of music I'd choose for a Desert Island.
7 * Johnstons - Brady again, part of hugely talented Irish quartet, later trio
8 * High Level Ranters - the cream of North-eastern music and the band that did more thany any other to lure me from rock to folk
9 * The Dubliners - when fronted by the late Luke Kelly, the combination of passionate vocals and fiery musicianship was irresistible
10 * Ensembles assembled or headed by Sharon Shannon or Karen Polwart
There you have my preferences - at the time of writing. It's a feast, but a moveable one. Do not be put off by the folk-dominated lists. Just go ahead and nominate your own, any genre.
Some excellent musicians in there - some of whom I’ve seen play live: Paul Brady as a solo artist and Renbourn and Jansch in Pentangle days. I still have the first Kate and Anna vinyl album, one with the haunting ‘Go Leave’ and ‘Heart Like A Wheel’.
Posted by: Jon Marks | April 21, 2020 at 02:02 PM
Not sure I can muster 10 and certainly not 10 of each. So, a mixed bag...
Simon & Garfunkel
High Level Ranters
Therapy (for anyone who remembers them - Sam Bracken, Dave Shannon and Fiona Simpson)
Ian Campbell Folk Group
Richard and Linda Thompson
Everly Brothers (I saw them live opening for Simon & Garfunkel and ending the evening on stage together - the makings of an acoustic supergroup!)
Incredible String Band
Posted by: Bill Taylor | April 21, 2020 at 02:45 PM
Therapy came to me in my sleep and I then completely forgot them. There may be a tweak coming
Posted by: colin | April 21, 2020 at 03:31 PM
Kate and Annie's 'Heart like a Wheel" c'mon I am amazed, they are exceptionally good.
Every song on that album drips memories and happiness beyond understanding, Lowell George played on it, one cannot get a bigger testament than that, I have the versions of Linda Ronstadt and Bette Midler's cover versions of 'Talk to Me of Mendocino'. Happy days Colin, incredibly happy days. Thank you for reminding me.
Posted by: Michael Murray | April 21, 2020 at 04:24 PM
Richard Thompson and Nanci Griffith's live version of "Vincent Black Lightning, 1952" is hard to beat:
Posted by: Bill Taylor | April 21, 2020 at 05:09 PM
Great song and performance of it and Richard Thompson will be very high in my next list, singer-songwriters. not sure he and Nanci constitute a duo. I even left out Dylan and Baez who occasionally sang together. Richard and Linda was a bad omission. But I think I prefer Simon without Garfunkel
Posted by: Colin | April 21, 2020 at 08:01 PM
I forgot The Carpenters!
Posted by: Bill Taylor | April 22, 2020 at 02:24 AM
Karen had a gorgeous voice. I used to know whose fabulous guitar solo DJs infuriatingly but routinely cut out at the end of Goodbye to Love .
Posted by: Colin | April 22, 2020 at 02:22 PM
Little-known (I think) fact about Karen - she started out as the Carpenters’ drummer and was highly rated for her abilities. She only reluctantly took on the lead vocalist’s role.
Posted by: Bill Taylor | April 22, 2020 at 02:36 PM
Not established duos but if Bill Taylor can get away with Nanci & Richard....Both of these duets feature Iris DeMent, a country/folk artist whose voice divides music fans. It has a hard, abrasive edge which some hate, I love it.
The first one is with the recently departed John Prine, feauturing his usual witty lyrics, you won't hear a love song like this anywhere else.
The second is another love song, this time Iris is with Steve Earle and backed by bluegrass boys The Del McCoury Band, when Iris sings the second verse the hairs on my arms regularly stand to attention.
Posted by: Jake | June 02, 2020 at 09:20 AM
Oh, and let's not forget Tír na nÓg.....https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdD8QaNVMtQ
Posted by: Jake | June 02, 2020 at 10:37 AM