Author: Colin Randall
Cover Story - same songs, different versions - has been running for a while now. This is a slightly unusual addition to the series ...
But February made me shiver
With every paper I'd deliver
Bad news on the doorstep
I couldn't take one more step
My paper round days started after Don McLean's. But I suspect I would have felt a little the same had the papers in my bag in the mid-1960s carried front-page news of Buddy Holly's death in an air crash.
Holly's music was difficult to dislike for young lads and lasses growing up during his tragically short career and for a few years afterwards. It was simple but irresistibly catchy; the lyrics expressed everyday emotions - ones we had or aspired to - and the tunes were memorable.
Rave On was among his best songs or rather one of the best songs he recorded since he didn't write it. I find no fault with it but - for the purposes of this, the 36th and latest edition of Cover Story - I do know of a version I like even more.
Step forward Steeleye Span.
This is the English electric folk band - they always preferred that description to folk-rock - that changed my life. I had hitched or taken a cheap night bus to London and was browsing in the shop of Cecil Sharp House, home of the English Folk Dance and Song Society, when someone put on Steeleye's ground-breaking album, Please To See The King. It was 1971 and I was there and then hooked on what I came to accept as, indeed, folk-rock.
Rave On was part of Steeleye's repertoire at the time but not part of that album, or at least not until it was re-released 20 years later.
It was one of the novelty songs the band liked to include. Listening on YouTube, I noticed that Rave On was followed on the playlist by New York Girls, on which Peter Sellers played ukelele. Thinking back, there was also a version (which I loved) of To Know Him Is To Love Him.
Here, Rave On is turned into an a capella piece with Maddy Prior ostensibly taking a back seat as Martin Carthy's stretched opening line "well, it's the little things you say and do ..." sets the tone. I say ostensibly because Prior's contributions in chorus and harmonies are sublime.
Not, I suspect for everyone. Purists, Holly fanatics and those who simply disgaree with me can now feast on the original ... and I do not mind in the least if, unlike me, you still prefer it.